Life After Harry Potter
Life After H P
Home

Luna Lovegood Luna Lovegood

and the Watch of Doom and the Watch of Doom

Page 82

by

James E. Pettis

Chapter Six

Detection

Xenophilius looked up in alarm at this, and Luna shared his reaction.  This was “the boy who lived,” the only known deterrent to the dark wizard Voldemort.  Twice now, Harry Potter had defeated the villain, once when he was no more than an infant, and again last spring.  At that time he was a first-year student at Hogwarts, almost completely unskilled in magic.7  Some of the most accomplished wizards and witches known had died at Voldemort’s hands.  Young Harry Potter had defeated him twice with some innate magical ability unknown to others of his kind.

“There must be a reason,” whispered Xenophilius, “something that we’re missing.  This could have been some sort of attack that Potter was defending against.  Some missile could have hurled toward him from outside the range of the Mumsy.”

Please leave a critical comment!
Some of my concerns:
  • What do you think of an outsider’s (Luna’s) evaluation of Harry, particularly his successes against Voldemort?
  • What do you think about the projectile loophole?  Now that you know the system, can you think of any other ways that magic could be used and falsely blamed on a student?

“Well,” responded their guide thoughtfully, “I must admit, I hadn’t considered that.  If some projectile were hurled by magic from outside the range of the Mumsy — or even within the range, in the unlikely event that some force other than magic was used — then our friend might use a Levitation spell to deflect the missile.  If such a thing were to happen, though, it would come out in any eventual hearing.  The law excuses magic in self-defense, even within view of Muggles.”

“My real concern here,” Xenophilius worried, “is that Harry Potter might have been attacked!  We sit here not knowing what happened!”

“My understanding, off the record . . .” the wizard replied, pausing.

“Off the record,” Xenophilius agreed.

“. . . is that Mr. Potter is being watched by the Ministry, and that his safety is a top priority with the Minister himself.”8

Please leave a critical comment!
Some of my concerns:
  • Is it reasonable that, prior to book four and Fudge’s “disowning” of Harry and Dumbledore, that the Ministry was keeping tabs on Harry all along?  I conjecture that a Ministry agent — probably an Auror — was stationed outside the Potter house at all times in case an agent of Voldemort tried to do away with him.  This explains why Fudge was able to track Harry in book three, even though Harry was not employing magic to travel to The Leaky Cauldron.  It also explains why Sirius didn’t contact Harry at Privet Drive.
If you would like a response to your comments or have questions, please e-mail your questions or comments to me at the address email@life-after-harry-potter.com.
Page 82
Valid XHTML 1.1! Valid CSS! Page design by

HARRY POTTER, characters, names and related indicia are trademarks of and © Warner Bros.  Harry Potter Publishing Rights © J. K. Rowling.  All rights reserved.  All uses of material subject to these copyrights on this site are used without permission.  All material presented here is intended solely for the enjoyment of the reader and is not authorized for copy or resale.  To fully enjoy this story, the reader should be in possession of all of the Harry Potter books by J. K. Rowling, but especially the first two, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone and Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.

Any and all copyright priveleges not belonging to the aforementioned, including the entirety of this web site design and content, are copyright © 2007-2008 by James E. Pettis This page copyright © 2008 by James E. Pettis

About this web site